The 2026 Ballon d’Or marks 20 years since the last time a defender won football’s most prestigious individual award, with Fabio Cannavaro’s triumph in 2006 the most recent example of a defender achieving every footballer’s pinnacle. Virgil van Dijk came within touching distance in 2019, though he ultimately lost by just 7 points to Lionel Messi in one of the tightest Ballon d’Or outcomes ever. Historically, only 3 defenders have ever won the honour, with Cannavaro joined by the illustrious Franz Beckenbauer, who prevailed in 1972 and 1976, whilst compatriot Matthias Sammer was victorious in 1996. Yet, for an award that has run for 70 years, this is a remarkably small cohort to represent one of the most influential positions in the team.
This year, we were left without a single defender inside the top 10. FC Barcelona’s Pau Cubarsí topped the rankings with his 12th-place finish, closely followed by PSG’s Achraf Hakimi in 13th. But why are they so low?

If we look at trophies won, both of these players sit at the same table as the talent inside the top 10. Cubarsí won the World Cup and La Liga, whilst Hakimi took home the Champions League and Ligue 1. However, silverware alone clearly cannot explain the rankings. Were this the case, Fabián Ruiz would be in strong contention to win, yet he finished tenth. The question is then not simply who has won the most, but whose contribution to those triumphs is considered most significant. This raises the possibility that a defender’s contribution is undervalued not due to their level of importance, but instead because of how that importance is perceived.
Defenders regularly fail to be awarded the same level of acclaim as attackers, with even Lamine Yamal seeming to acknowledge this at this year’s ceremony. ‘I would have liked to see my team-mate Cubarsí here because I think this prize should have been for him,’ he said upon accepting the Kopa trophy for the third year running. And although the award is decided by an international panel of journalists, these voters are not immune to the same perceptions that may shape your football chat down the pub. The Ballon d’Or is not just a measure of individual performance, but an opinion on it. It’s natural to form favourable judgements based on what captures our attention. The award’s criteria themselves even stipulate that individual performances should be ‘decisive and impressive’. As such, in a sport where attacking brilliance is so often the deciding factor, it is unsurprising that defenders struggle to achieve the same level of recognition as the game-changers.
People want goals. Fans love wingers that humiliate opposing full-backs, silky-smooth midfielders that run the show, or clinical strikers who change games in an instant. It’s rare for a defender to be described as ‘entertaining’. And yet, despite all this, the appreciation for quality defending remains. I think I celebrated Djed Spence’s tackle against Argentina more than I did Gordon’s goal. And so much of the issue lies in the infrequency of these moments. Flashes of attacking brilliance occur week after week, while a defender’s best work often involves preventing a dangerous situation from developing in the first place. Although a superb goal-line clearance or last-ditch tackle continues to impress, these moments are far less frequent. Whilst defenders may notch up a string of faultless games, their lack of defining moments means it is often others who gain the headlines instead.

Of course, performing in big games is essential for any hopeful recipient of the Ballon d’Or, but these fixtures always tend to increase scrutiny on those protecting their own goal. Everyone remembers a defensive error to consign your team to defeat, but who’s pointing fingers at the wasteful strikers? In a world dominated by goals and assists (G/A) statistics, an attacker could miss several clear-cut chances and be excused, as long as his numbers adjudge that he’s having a decent season overall. This consistent baseline of measured output allows strikers to fall back on such statistics to evidence their standard of performance across the course of a season (whether they’ve missed a few sitters or not).
Conversely, there is yet to be a single metric that can adequately capture a defender’s individual contribution. The strength of G/A is its comparability, and whilst it doesn’t cover every facet of performance, it remains a simple and widely understood measure of output that cannot be replicated for defenders. Clean sheet statistics depend heavily on the goalkeeper and wider team, whilst tackles and interception numbers are influenced by tactics and specific situational moments. Key qualities such as positioning or awareness are similarly difficult to quantify. As a result, perceptions on defenders effectively always come through the subjective ‘eye-test’, with viewers left to interpret quality for themselves. Whilst this is not necessarily a bad thing, it causes problems within the context of the Ballon d’Or’s voting system. When journalists must compare players across different positions, the easily quantifiable G/A statistics offer a convenient point of reference. As such, it is difficult to escape the idea that this gives attackers an inherent advantage.

Ultimately, for a defender to break the cycle, a number of factors are required to fall into place. They must be central to a trophy-winning side, producing performances that capture the public’s eye, all the while hoping that no forward enjoys a season extraordinary enough to overshadow them. Each of the three success stories from the past took up irreplaceable roles in teams that either won the European Cup, or prestigious national trophies. Van Dijk appeared to fulfill this brief in 2019, leading Liverpool to a first Champions League in 14 years, yet he was up against a man who registered 70 G/A in 50 games. This is the overarching challenge for defenders, as in a current climate dominated by goalscoring machines and wing wizards, it seems there will always be someone to outshine them. In short, as long as attackers are getting fans off their seats, the defenders will remain sat down come award night.




Leave a Reply